The
Writing on the Walls: Memories of Joanie and Chris
I
have written some memories of the remarkable couple that was Chris
and my cousin, Joanie, each of whom I knew a little for a brief while
and each of whom died tragically young in their mid-thirties, leaving
behind eight beautiful children.
A
lot of studies have been done on memory which indicate memories
actually change and decay with age. Therefore, I begin this story
with a disclaimer; memories may actually tell you more about the one
remembering than they do about those remembered.
And,
too, I can remember Joanie's voice as if I had spoken to her
yesterday, and I can surely remember the essences of conversations
we've had, but with few exceptions (those actual quotes which
follow), I cannot remember the actual words from those conversations
30 years ago and more.
And
yet, I do not think I'm totally mistaken in my perceptions...
Although
I was only three or four years older than she, Joanie was one of my
"younger" cousins growing up. The thing I remember most
about her as a child was her reputed intelligence. Aunt Mary always
noted that Joanie, (unlike myself), and unlike her nineteen siblings (yes, my aunt and uncle had twenty single birth biological children) who all
sported impressive verbal chops, was also good at math! The
possession of such a rarefied aptitude in our family was thought to
herald a brilliant future at, you know, figuring things out.
But
Joanie was also raised to value family and spiritual integrity over
worldly aspirations such as status and prestige. Thus, Joanie's gift
with numbers was celebrated only anecdotally - a special idiosyncrasy
to add to the constellation of Joanie's many other qualities.
Indeed, in my mind, Joanie seemed to be a real rockstar of a Kelly!
I
can remember hanging out in the barn with Joanie and her sisters and
brothers who all seemed to harbor secrets my brother-less and
slightly envious self found to be thrilling.
Their collective aura of cryptic teenage omniscience was reinforced
when, upon walking upstairs in their house, one could discern writing
scrawled directly on the walls. A moment's inspection revealed the
graffiti to be no ordinary vandalism, but pure poetry! But who was
the author? I don't even remember what the words said, but the sight
of them astonished me no less than would have the sight of
petroglyphs carved into the pink wall in the girl's bathroom stall or
in finding a sanskrit illuminated manuscript underneath my pedal
pushers in my dresser drawer.
The
writer of the poetry remains a mystery to this day. In fact, none of
the cousins I recently queried seem to remember the writing on the
walls at all. Thus, I have become quite convinced the bard was none
other than Joanie herself.
In
addition to being the possessor of what I imagined to be an esoteric
intellect, I also found Joanie to be physically beautiful as well.
She had long, straight, brown hair, high cheekbones and intense,
deep-set, blue eyes. The Kellys were very poor in material things, of
course, so Joanie's clothes were well-worn, but she wore them well.
And besides, it was the 60's and 70's. Joanie was never out of style
in jeans and t-shirts or peasant style blouses and dresses; in short,
she cut the figure of an exceptionally lovely flower child.
Of
course, Joanie did not follow flower child protocol. She had very
strong views on things and the Catholicism with which she was raised
would always exert a tremendous influence on her character, even when
she underwent a "rebellious" phase as a teenager. My
memory of this, however, is only as reliable as 30 year old
confessions from Joanie or reports from second and third party
sources can be.
Although
the drive to the Kellys only took a couple hours, it seemed as if my
cousins lived in another time and country; thus, we did not visit
them nearly often enough for my taste. I remember one trip which
included a harrowing drive in the snow down a narrow, winding road
through mountain rock cuts. It seemed as if our car would go
careening over the cliff at any moment!
Just
a few months ago, Theresa described the area near their house as
having been the site of a ghost town. Indeed, all the buildings -
including their house - which I recall as having been denuded of
paint, seemed to all be in the process of reclamation by nature. In
short, I found the land, the buildings, the poetry on the walls - to
be nothing less than enchanted.
As
happens, our teen years flew by and like many others from rural,
socioeconomically challenged milieu, most of us could not wait to
leave home, fall in love and get married. I married before the age of
twenty, as did many of my cousins, including Joanie.
My
husband and I bought a trailer and lived in "Jackson's Trailer
Court" for a year or two before moving it to twenty acres we
eventually bought further out in the country. The property had been
the site of an abandoned hippie commune that burned to the ground.
The farmers who had been neighbors to the "long-hairs" in
residence reported scandalous "goings on" there, including
goats roaming freely through the house to serve as Satanic midwives
to she-hippies who frequented skinny-dipping parties and were
perpetually giving birth to - good god - more miniature hippies!
These
rumors only imbued the property with a greater ambience for me -
property which included three distinct habitats: mature forest,
meadow, and, best of all...hippie steeped wetlands. I relished
exploring the grounds and would sit by one of three ponds with
binoculars in hand observing the aviary of birds from all three
ecosystems that shared the land with us: baltimore orioles,
bluebirds, great blue herons, little green herons, flickers,
warblers, cedar waxwings and on and on. Needless to say, it was a
melodious plot and I was one happy amateur ornithologist!
It
was at this point in time that Joanie would enter my life again - not
merely as a younger sister in the Kelly clan this time, but as a
young newlywed who just moved to my hometown!
It
began with a phone call from Joanie to me to announce her new
residence. Her husband, Chris (who just so happened to be from the Bronx!), had just landed a job at DuPont, one
of three local industries in town. DuPont was reputed to be "the
best place to work" around. It was the cleanest factory and
DuPont employees - even those who worked in production - enjoyed good
salaries. If I remember correctly, Chris was a computer programmer,
so he fared even better than others I knew.
Still,
I worried a little bit about how my cousins would fare as newcomers
to Towanda. I knew the locals frequently resented "city people"
invading their territory. But Chris was not just any city person,
he was a non-Caucasian city person! Most shocking of all was that he
and Joanie were a mixed race couple! I honestly believe that Chris
was the only black person in Towanda at the time and I am certain
that he and Joanie comprised the solitary mixed race married couple.
This
fact made me only love and admire Joanie all the more for her courage
in being true to herself and to her new husband. Likewise, I admired
Chris from the start for the same reasons as well as his courage in
starting a new life in a place that could be so hostile - even racist
- to outsiders.
What
an enrichment it was to get to know Joanie better and Chris for the
first time. Chris was a tall, soft-spoken gentle man and one of the things that impressed me the most about Chris was his
humility. Although he was from a comparatively well-to-do family from
the big city, he never looked down on the provincials that we truly
were. In fact, he even took my husband and me to stay a few days
with his parents in NYC. It was our first time in the city!
Our
roles had reversed, as this time, Hugh and I were the outsiders. I
remember that Chris was really proud to show us around. When he drove
us into Manhattan, we heard lots of loud bangs which we found
unnerving to say the least. Since we were always told how "dangerous"
the big bad city was, our first thought was gunfire!
Without calling out our hillbilly naivete, Chris simply chuckled
good-naturedly and reminded us what day it was: the fourth of July!
He
took us to the Bronx Zoo, the Museum of Natural History, to his
parents' lovely condo and introduced us to White Castle hamburgers!
Chris's parents were just as gracious as Chris was. They showed us
the utmost hospitality and took time to share with us stories about
their lives in the city as a teacher (his mom) and postal worker (his
dad).
In
addition to the NYC trip, Chris and Joanie and Hugh and I got
together on a few occasions to have dinner or go driving on the
mountains or hiking out on our property which Chris and Joanie loved
as much as we did. Whether we met at our trailer or in Chris and
Joanie's apartment, the atmosphere was always very relaxed with a
"what's mine is yours" sort of ethic always prevailing.
One
time, Chris asked to brush his teeth in our bathroom. "Sure,"
I said, "go right ahead." It was then I realized he
didn't have his own toothbrush, but wanted to use mine! I knew that
he would have been perfectly happy to share his toothbrush with me,
so how could I refuse him the implement I stuck in my mouth twice a
day to remove plaque from my teeth and anaerobes
from betwixt the papillae and taste-buds on my tongue? "Go for
it," I said, and he did!
Indeed,
Chris was the kind of person who would have given you the shirt off
his back if you needed it, and it was this total unconcern for
"things of this world" which always imbued both Chris and
Joanie with this aura of actually being
"not of this world" even when they were very much with us.
In retrospect, it would be easy to believe that they had stepped down
from the very ether to coexist with those of us mortal beings who
were much more attached to the stuff and the "goings on" of
the material world than they were.
At
this time in their lives, Chris and Joanie did not drink or smoke or
express any desire to attend parties - not ever. They felt no desire
or need to impress others with their appearances, their possessions
or their "achievements." They were content to live quietly
and simply with each other, their ADORABLE baby boy and "another
one on the way." Their purpose in life was to live the life they
believed God wanted them to live. And so they did with as much
courage, patience, faith, humility and integrity as I have ever seen.
As
I already mentioned, Joanie was unattached to material things, but
she was positively passionate about life and her values. She was
"pro-life" in the biggest sense of the word. It caused her
great pain to live in a world in which abortion happened, but it also
caused her great pain to live in a world in which any living thing
suffered. For Joanie, all life was precious - even animal life. She
was not a vegetarian, but would not hesitate to help an animal in
need if it was within her capability to do so. Neither she, nor
Chris, hunted, and although she supported those serving in the
military (she would have brothers who would do so), the thought of
war or any kind of violence also caused her great pain.
The
current debate over gun control prompts me to wonder WWJD? ("J"
for Joanie, not Jesus here!) In all honesty (as in I am not just
writing this to bolster my own politics), the thought of Chris and
Joanie being gun-owners today is all but unfathomable to me. To
imagine either of them packing heat would be about as absurd as
seeing Gandhi with a Bushmaster slung over his shoulder exchanging
pleasantries with Ted Nugent. Just wouldn't have happened!
But
it was the thought of abortion which disturbed Joanie the most. She
spoke of it EVERY time we were together. I must admit that while I
admired her conviction and her willingness to speak out, her
obsession with abortion could be exhausting for this listener. The
simple truth is that we had different views in this regard. While
the thought of abortion greatly disturbed me, too, I also felt great
compassion for young women who experienced unwanted pregnancies for
one reason or another. I know Joanie also felt empathy for these
girls, but it was her opinion that the horror - and guilt - of
abortion would only make their situations harder. I disagreed that
this was always the case and/or felt that the undue horror and guilt
some girls experienced were culturally imposed upon them. I subdued
my own opinions, however, in deference to Joanie's all-consuming
conviction. After all, my whole family felt so strongly about the
issue, I feared their wrath or my own father's displeasure were I to
come out as a heretic, blasphemer, feminist and LIBERAL!
This
conflict within me - the part that wanted to express my very strong
opinions vs. the part that wanted to keep the peace - would become so
great, I would eventually estrange myself from people I loved, but
with whom I strongly disagreed about too many things. I am now
wishing I had had the strength of character to have been able to
express my views at family gatherings and let the chips fall where
they may. Instead, I just found it easier to avoid any potential
drama and my own guilt that would be sure to follow.
Of
course, Joanie's pro-life stance also sprung from her love of
children and what I saw as her desire to emulate her own mother whom
she clearly loved to pieces. I remember her affectionately joking
about Aunt Mary, "My mother is crazy. Who has twenty children?
Nobody does that!" (I think Adam was born by then, but I could
be wrong). Of course, Joanie would go on to have eight children of
her own in a time when having two children - if any at all - was the
norm!
In
contrast to Chris and Joanie, Hugh and I were very much part of the
world. I have to admit that the words "selfish" and
"hedonistic" would not have been completely out of place in
a sentence containing our names. We had no intention of having
children immediately and were very much into partying with friends,
experiencing new things and acquiring worldly knowledge. I had been
attending college part time and when I was 24, Hugh and I would go
off to the university full-time.
This
was very difficult for Joanie to understand. "Why would you
want to move away when you worked so hard to acquire your land?"
In Joanie's mind, we already had it all - more than any person could
possibly want, in fact. Although we lived in a trailer and I worked
as a secretary and my husband as a factory worker, we were rich
compared to many others in my family, so she was right. Still, I was
intolerably restless. My ambition, my curiosity and desire to learn
new things and meet new people could not be suppressed, so Hugh and I
moved three hours away to go to college and Chris and Joanie moved
away to to a new life, new job and new burgeoning family in Texas.
Thus,
the brief time we lived in the same community came to an end and,
tragically and regrettably, I would never see Joanie or Chris again.
A lot of concentrated life happened in the years immediately
following our moves. Hugh and I moved away from home for the first
time, we began college as non-traditional students, I began a new job
as a teacher, my father got sick with cancer and died and, at 34, I
had a baby boy of my own. I had imagined that Chris and Joanie had
become equally immersed in their new lives and since neither Joanie,
nor I, were good at writing letters we completely lost touch. If only
we had facebook and e-mail back then!
In
many ways, however, Chris and Joanie do not feel any farther away
today than when we were sharing chuckles, food and toothbrushes.
Although Joanie was my cousin and we shared many traits as members of
most extended families do, in many respects, there was always a part
of Joanie that was completely inaccessible, mysterious and, yes,
ethereal to me. And her husband, Chris, was exactly the same way.
Why
do tragic things happen to good people in the prime of their lives?
Nobody knows the answer to that. But I do know that even if I was
never moved to completely emulate Chris and Joanie's lives or
subscribe to all of their religious beliefs, these two people
affected me in deep and profound ways. Each of them embodied a level
of decency and humanity that is rarely seen. Even today, when it is
easy to despair of the seemingly omnipresent evil in the hearts of my
fellow human beings, I think of Chris and Joanie and know that
goodness itself prevails long after the the body has perished.
The
proof of that is evident first and foremost in the lives of their
children: children both sensitive and strong enough to endure tragedy
that would break many - if not most - other children. Children who
have grown up with the talent and potential to continue their
parent's legacy of world-changing good will. Credit for this must be
given, not only to Chris and Joanie, but to their grand-parents,
aunts, uncles, and other family members who took their nieces and
nephews in and raised them as their own sons and daughters. Indeed,
Chris and Joanie's goodness is evident in the voices and gestures of
their sisters and brothers, mothers and fathers!
It
is also evident in Chris and Joanie's PIONEERING examples of
exceptional love and conviction in the face of racism, hate and
ignorance. Because of their union, the path has been made easier for
other people to follow: for ALL of us to more freely love others
regardless of ethnicity, nationality, religion or any number of
superficial and divisive externals that alienate us from each other.
One could argue that Chris and Joanie's non-traditional union has
helped pave the way for people to accept other non-traditional
unions, including those within the LGBT community.
In
sum, Chris and Joanie's goodness was never, in my view, exactly of
this world. And that is exactly why it endures.
Indeed,
this goodness, this love
of
theirs,
is
what will always be my PERFECT memory
of
the writing on the walls!